This is Rick Glen Strandlof, a wounded Marine captain. Strandlof, a Colorado graduate of the United States Naval Academy, has an impressive resume. He survived the September 11th attacks on the Pentagon, served three tours in Iraq, was wounded during the battle for the Iraqi city of Fallujah and received the Purple Heart.
This is Xavier Alvares, a retired Marine who served 25 years, was wounded numerous times, and was awarded the Medal of Honor in 1987.
The problem?
Both men are lying.
Neither man has ever served in the military. Alvares was never awarded the Medal of Honor. Strandlof was never awarded a Purple Heart or Silver Star.
Both men were arrested and charged under The Stolen Valor Act.
Nothing crazy about any of that so far, right?
These two are not the only ones to claim military honors they did not earn. They aren't the only two who have, by their actions, diminished the truly heoric actions of the men and women who have served, were wounded, and did those truly unbelievable things medal winners do.
These two men, however, weren't content to take admit their lies, take the punishment, and disappear in disgrace as they damned well should have.
No, these two men are challenging The Stolen Valor Act on the grounds that it is unconstitutional.
Their argument? They have a right to lie under the free speech provision of the Constitution of the United States.
Consider this:
Jonathan Turley, a professor at George Washington University Law School who is not involved in the two cases, said the Stolen Valor Act raises serious constitutional questions because it in effect bans bragging or exaggerating about yourself.Have we really become that unmoored from any sort of sense of what is right and just? Do people not understand the difference?
“Half the pickup lines in bars across the country could be criminalized under that concept,” he said
'Hey, baby, I'm a surgeon.' is not the same thing as saying 'Hey, baby, I won the Medal of Honor.'
One is a lie that affects two people - the teller and the unfortunate fool that believes him.
The other diminishes something that should never, ever be diminished; not for personal gain, not for profit, not for anything.
And if we truly do not understand that we have completely lost our way and I fear for the future.
I will allow George Washington the final words here. He was speaking of the Purple Heart, which he created:
“Should any who are not entitled to these honors have the insolence to assume the badges of them, they shall be severely punished.”







